5 Tips for Talking Across Differences and Disagreements

Intergroup Dialogue Training Center Co-Directors Jazmin Pichardo and Carlton Green Offer Guidance for Productive Conversations in Polarized Times
DialogueReadySeries

With the November election quickly approaching, heated political rhetoric and contentious debates have underscored the challenges of discussing diverse viewpoints in today鈥檚 polarized climate. Now more than ever, schools and communities are engaged in efforts to teach youth how to talk across political differences.

Recognizing the importance of equipping University of 浪花直播 students, faculty and staff with the skills to engage in conversations around complex issues, the College of Education and the Office of Undergraduate Studies collaboratively launched the Intergroup Dialogue Training Center in Spring 2024. Under the leadership of co-Directors Jazmin Pichardo and Carlton Green, the center serves as a campuswide resource for dialogue facilitation training, curricular support and ongoing professional development. It will prepare faculty to implement new general education requirements that aim to help students understand the structural dimension of racism and develop skills for engaging across differences. The center鈥檚 goal is to foster a culture of meaningful, productive conversations across diverse sociocultural, political, ideological and disciplinary perspectives on campus.

鈥淎t a fundamental level, we all share a need and desire to belong鈥搕o feel that we matter to the communities we are a part of and that the issues that most affect us are worth acknowledging and addressing,鈥 says Pichardo. 

To help foster these types of productive conversations in the classroom, Pichardo and Green offer these five tips:

  1. Reframe conversations as opportunities for growth. Often, these types of discussions are labeled as 鈥渃ontentious,鈥 鈥渄ivisive鈥 or 鈥減olarizing.鈥 Green, who brings a counseling psychology background to diversity dialogues, explains that these terms imply a goal of achieving harmony or consensus, which can result in conversations that suppress or diminish dissenting or diverse viewpoints. Instead, he suggests framing these discussions as 鈥渘ecessary鈥 and 鈥渃onstructive.鈥 This shift in perspective emphasizes fostering community and collaboration rather than seeking agreement. By viewing disagreements as opportunities for growth and understanding, students and faculty can facilitate more open, productive dialogues.
     
  2. Create a brave (not just safe) space. Cultivating environments where students feel both physically and emotionally secure is essential. Equally important is ensuring that students are comfortable sharing their perspectives. 鈥淚n brave spaces, students are encouraged to question biases, challenge assumptions and engage in meaningful dialogue,鈥 says Pichardo. 鈥淭hese spaces empower students to take risks, make mistakes and, most importantly, learn from one another.鈥 

    To establish brave spaces, cocreate discussion norms, build trust and openly define what bravery means for everyone involved. 鈥淩emember, conflict is inevitable in these conversations,鈥 Pichardo notes. 鈥淚t's crucial to work together to navigate these moments constructively.鈥
     
  3. Embrace and manage emotions. Fear is a powerful emotion and can sometimes play a role in our efforts to face and discuss disagreements. Instead of suppressing emotions, embrace them as important aspects of dialogue that help promote understanding and connection. 鈥淚dentifying, naming, communicating and responding to one鈥檚 own鈥揳s well as others鈥欌揺motions are skills that help with navigating conflicts and communicating care to others,鈥 says Green. He also emphasizes the importance of promoting empathy, which can help students connect with each other, understand their peers鈥 perspectives and experiences, and build mutual respect.
     
  4. Lean into first draft thinking. In educational settings, there鈥檚 often pressure to demonstrate competence and provide the correct answers. Pichardo and Green challenge that notion by embracing 鈥渇irst draft thinking.鈥 鈥淚t鈥檚 OK to offer emerging ideas, perspectives or observations, even if they鈥檙e still being processed,鈥 says Green. This mindset not only promotes a culture of curiosity and learning but also makes it easier for students to engage with diverse perspectives. 
     
  5. Focus on collaborative solutions. 鈥淚n dialogue, we are seeking to build relationships across differences in order to collaboratively solve problems,鈥 says Pichardo. Encourage students to identify shared goals and explore how different perspectives can contribute to innovative solutions.  

鈥淎 healthy democracy, or a healthy classroom, relies on the ability of its members to engage in constructive dialogue, even when they disagree,鈥 says Pichardo. 鈥淥ur past is rich with examples of leaders engaging in robust and thoughtful discourse from diverse viewpoints, and it is these very exchanges that continue to shape and sustain a democracy that strives to serve everyone.鈥